Tucked into the Republic of Rathnelly, one of Toronto's most unique and tightly held neighbourhoods, this striking Gable-Front Victorian offers a rare combination of scale, character, and location. Set on a quiet, tree-lined street where neighbours know each other and homes rarely come to market, this is the kind of address buyers wait years for. Inside, soaring ceilings on every level create a sense of volume rarely found, with a main floor that blends elegance and function through a formal living room with wood burning fireplace, a dining room with gas fireplace, and a kitchen that anchors daily life and entertaining. The second floor offers two bedrooms plus a flexible den easily converted back to a fifth, along with laundry and a primary suite with California Closets built-ins. The third floor adds two more bedrooms, including one with an integrated study area, and a walkout terrace above the city. A largely unspoiled lower level with wine cellar and side walkout offers exceptional future potential. Detached garage via shared drive with potential for additional rear parking. Steps to Summerhill, Nordheimer Ravine, Pump Park, transit, and within the coveted Brown School catchment. A rare opportunity in a true neighbourhood setting.
Address
204 Cottingham Street
List Price
$2,895,000
MLS® Status
New
Expiration Date
2026-07-30
Property Type
Residential Freehold
Type of Dwelling
Semi-Detached
Style of Home
3-Storey
Transaction Type
Sale
Area
Toronto C02
Sub-Area
Casa Loma
Region
Toronto
Bedrooms
4 + 2
Bedrooms (Total)
6
Rooms Above Grade
10
Rooms Below Grade
3
Bathrooms
4
Floor Area
2500-3000 Sq. Ft.
Lot Size Source
MPAC
Lot Depth
140
Lot Size Units
Feet
Lot Width
25.75
Parcel Number
212180279
Occupant Type
Owner
Cross Street
Avenue Road and Cottingham Street
MLS® Number
C12991686
Listing Brokerage
ROYAL LEPAGE/J & D DIVISION
Basement Area
Separate Entrance, Unfinished
Postal Code
M4V 1C5
Posession Details
60/90/120
Parking
Mutual
Parking Places (Total)
1
Tax Amount
$15,492.01
Tax Year
2026
Site Influences
Fenced Yard, Lawn Sprinkler System, Park, Patio, Privacy, Public Transit, School
Exterior Features
Lawn Sprinkler System, Patio, Privacy
Interior Features
In-Law Capability, Storage
Property Features
Fenced Yard, Park, Public Transit, School
Central Vacuum
No
Family Room
No
Ensuite Laundry
No
Special Designation
Unknown
Standard Status
Active
Board Or Association
Toronto Regional Real Estate Board
Heat Source
Gas
Heat Type
Forced Air
Cooling Features
Central Air
Construction Materials
Brick
Direction Faces
North
Fireplace
Yes
Fireplace Features
Wood, Natural Gas
Foundation Details
Stone, Brick
Garage
Yes
Garage Type
Detached
Covered Spaces
1
Kitchens Total
1
Kitchens Above Grade
1
Pool Features
None
Roof
Slate
Tax Legal Description
PCL 7-1 SEC M55; LT 7 PL M55 TORONTO ; T/W A ROW FOR THE PURPOSE OF A DRIVEWAY AND PASSAGEWAY TO BE APPURTENANT TO THE SAID LT 7 IN OVER ALONG AND UPON THE WLY 3 FT 6 INCHES OF THE SLY 95 FT OF LT A ON N/S OF COTTINGHAM ST ON PL M47; S/T A LIKE ROW FOR THE PURPOSE OF A DRIVEWAY AND PASSAGEWAY TO BE APPURTENANT TO THE SAID LT A IN OVER ALONG AND UPON THE ELY 3 FT 6 INCHES OF THE SLY 95 FT OF THE SAID LT 7; TORONTO , CITY OF TORONTO
Waterfront
No
Sewer
Sewer
Open Houses
- April 18, 1:00 PM - 5:00 PM
- April 19, 1:00 PM - 5:00 PM
